Have you noticed the news about the children of polygamy in Texas being rounded up and taken away ? News of this creates an unsettled and oppresive feeling for me.
These children are being gathered up/rounded up by the hundreds and taken away by Texas authority with what is purported to be a rescue operation to save them from alleged child abuse. Okay, that sounds like it's on the up-and-up so far. It is reported that the girls will be saved from sexual 'slavery' ...(okay, being married at much too young an age to who knows whom is not good)..and the boys will be prevented from becoming the predators that cause said abuse. (Hmm...not really okay to put the cart before the horse here, is it? It can't be proven that the boys will be perpetrators, can it ?) Can authorities take these children away because they assume they will be commiting this crime sometime in their lives?
So they say taking these kids into custody is protecting them from all this. It is assumed/known that members of this cult are disallowed the privelge of ever leaving their 'home.' That's abusive. It's imprisonment. So to go in and "rescue" them.....is that the right thing to do? Is it the only thing that can be done? Looks like it so far. Is it true that they can't leave? Is that propoganda on the state's part?
It bothers me that this is so close to denying them their constitutional right to freedom of religion. I wonder if the law is not acting from prejudice more than good will. On the other hand, there is a real possibility that they want/need to be rescued, that they are for the most part being held against their will. Can it be against their will if it's what they have been taught and it is the only thing they know?
6 years ago
4 comments:
I've been reading what I can about this because it brings up a lot of feelings in me. I'm not sure why, but glad to have the chance to discuss it here.
I read the SLTrib online and people are able to post comments on the articles. I was surprised how many comments there were in defense of the people and their rights. I really tried to see it from that view point, like the things you said here, but I simply can't.
There are CHILDREN there being made to do things that are just... well, not right. I think if only ONE 14 year old girl there is made to marry anyone (if he was the same age or close, it only makes them both a victim, it doesn't take away the sting) and forced into sexual relations it was worth trying to rescue her, especially given the fact that this is something taught and ingrained as their relationship to God. It doesn't matter if she's been taught it and believes in it. It doesn't matter if it's all she knows.
I don't think most people understand how sexual abuse, experience, exposure etc can hurt an innocent child. It's just way too much for a child to have to deal with before their own feelings, desires, baby-steps-into-it are ready.
I've read things recently about the sex trade in some countries, including ours, and children being forced into that. Perhaps that is more violent and this could be argued to be a loving, marital relationship and therefore different. But I can't see it. It is taking the innocence of children. Sex really is a HUGE thing and any force or lack of choice in it is so wrong. It destroys people. It destroys their spirits and who they are before they even have a chance to figure it out themselves. There is no hope for them ever getting it back. Nothing they can do but over come it and try to deal with it- like having their arm chopped off. They just have to learn to live without it.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMMENT. IT'S GOOD TO HAVE AN HONEST VIEWPOINT. iT HELPS MY THINKING AND I KNOW YOU ARE RIGHT.
Unfortunately, knowing what I know, I'd take everyone of those girls away. I'm not sure I agree on the male side that they would become predators, but the girls indeed would be irreversibly harmed. I've seen it first hand, had to deal with the consequences of sexual abuse and after watching my daughter go through what she's been through and still going through, she's much to mentally immature to handle such grown up things. Physical maturity and mental maturity do not go hand in hand....
I;ve been concerned I sounded harsh or responded emotionally. It's just interesting to me the different views people are taking to this and that whichever side you're on, we seem unable to understand the other way of thinking. It's such a weird... sociological thing to be looking at. I think it brings up a lot of questions about people and how we think, act, etc. Hm.
Post a Comment